**

by Gideon Madzikatidze / Simbarashe Sithole

PLUMTREE – A 28-year-old miner who went on a midnight arson spree after a dispute over unpaid piece jobs has been jailed for 10 months effective imprisonment by resident provincial magistrate Busani Sibanda at the Plumtree Magistrates Court.

Clive Dube pleaded guilty to three counts of malicious damage to property after admitting that he burnt down two thatched huts and a wooden fence belonging to three different victims in Madlambuzi, under Chief Masendu, on the night of 23 October 2026.

The court heard that Dube had done piece jobs for the three victims, but they allegedly teamed up and refused to pay him. He told the court they told him he could report them anywhere, as they were not going to pay him.

Angered by the refusal, Dube waited until nightfall and moved from homestead to homestead, setting the properties alight with fire before slipping away unnoticed.

His first victim was Loveness Dube of Tjidiwe Village, whose thatched hut was burnt down. The damage was valued at R15,000. His second victim was from the homestead of Keven Sibanda in Chingo Village, where a thatched hut was also set alight. A woman identified as Thobekile was asleep inside the hut at the time. Dube admitted in court that he did not check whether anyone was inside before setting the hut on fire.

“I erred,” he told the court.

His third victim was Hluphe Dube of Tjidiwe Village, whose wooden fence – which Dube himself had built for a fee – was burnt at around 10pm while the complainant was asleep. The total damage across all three properties was valued at R35,500 and nothing was recovered.

In mitigation, Dube, a father of one, told Magistrate Sibanda that he had overreacted to his emotions and failed to control his anger. He apologised to the victims and asked the court to temper justice with mercy so he could replace what he had destroyed. He told the court he works as a miner, earning ZAR18,000 a month, has ZAR18,000 in unpaid salary held by his employer and owns four cattle.

The State, however, argued that the offence was aggravated by premeditation, the use of fire, the fact that the offences were committed at night and that one victim was inside a hut when it was set alight. The victims, through their victim impact statements, said they were traumatised, suffered emotional and financial loss and had not been reimbursed.

Magistrate Sibanda said a fine or community service would trivialise the offence and erode public confidence in the courts. He said cases of this nature were on the rise and called for a deterrent sentence.

“The offender must pay for his sins. Norms and values of Ubuntu demand that we respect others’ property and do not resort to damaging others’ property when we feel offended,” Magistrate Sibanda said.

Dube was sentenced by Magistrate Sibanda on 26 October 2026 to 36 months’ imprisonment, with all three counts taken as one for sentence. Of that sentence, 10 months were suspended for 5 years on condition he does not commit another offence involving malicious damage to property. A further 6 months were suspended on condition he restitutes the first victim ZAR15,000 by 31 December 2026, while 5 months were suspended on condition he restitutes the second victim ZAR10,500 by the same date and another 5 months were suspended on condition he restitutes the third victim ZAR10,000 by 31 December 2026. The remaining 10 months is effective imprisonment.

Magistrate Sibanda told Dube he has a right to appeal, and that the record will in any event be sent to the High Court for automatic review within seven days.

By admin

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *